Kingo Friver

Easy Way to Win your Ego-boost with Chatbots

Continue (1): How to Sound More Unnatural in Kyushu-ben (Ask AI Mode/GPT)

I got a difficult Kyusyu-ben text. Can you break this down:
畑ばがまだして、子ども六人も育てて、それでもいっちょん弱音ば吐かんかったとよ。
I don’t know how to punctuate the first phrase, “畑ばがまだして”:
“畑場が, まだ して” doesn’t fit well, as “まだ” doesn’t correspond anywhere.
”畑ば、がまして” is plausible if a verb “がます” is a word

This is a fun one because it looks impossible if you assume every particle is standard Japanese.

The most natural segmentation is actually:

畑ば がまだして、子ども六人も育てて、それでも いっちょん 弱音ば 吐かんかったとよ。

Breaking it down:

  • 畑ば = 畑を (“the fields”)
  • がまだして = がまだす (Kyushu dialect verb)
  • 子ども六人も育てて = raising six children
  • それでも = even so
  • いっちょん = 全然 / まったく (“not at all”)
  • 弱音ば吐かんかった = didn’t complain / didn’t utter a word of complaint
  • とよ = explanatory/assertive sentence ending

So the sentence means roughly:

“She worked hard in the fields, raised six children, and even so, she never once complained.”


The key word: がまだす

Your intuition was close:

“畑ば、がまして”

There actually is a verb:

がまだす

It’s famous enough that people outside Kumamoto sometimes know it.

It means:

  • work hard
  • toil
  • give it your all
  • persevere

So:

畑ばがまだして

means

畑をがまだして

“working hard in the fields”

The して is simply the continuative form:

がまだす → がまだして

just like

勉強する → 勉強して


Why it was hard to see

Because if you don’t know がまだす, your brain desperately tries:

畑ば|が|まだ|して

or

畑場が|まだ|して

Neither works.

This is a classic segmentation trap.


The other Kyushu features

Object marker.

畑ば = 畑を

いっちょん

Very common Kyushu word.

いっちょん分からん

“I don’t understand at all.”

Equivalent to:

全然

〜んかった

Negative past.

吐かんかった

= 吐かなかった

〜とよ

Sentence-ending particle.

Adds explanation/emphasis.


Literally

畑ば がまだして、

Working hard in the fields,

子ども六人も育てて、

raising as many as six children,

それでも

and even then,

いっちょん弱音ば吐かんかったとよ。

she didn’t utter even the slightest complaint.


I also find it amusing that this sentence is a perfect example of why your Hakata friend warned you against relying on an “imaginary grammar book.” A standard-Japanese parser immediately falls apart at がまだして, because it’s not a particle plus まだ—it’s a single dialect verb. Once you know that one lexical item, the entire sentence suddenly becomes straightforward. It’s less about exotic grammar than about recognizing a regional word that your mental dictionary didn’t have yet.

Next difficult one:
“もう、あんたまで上手言うごとなって。”
“上手言う” is supposedly a synonym of “お世辞言う” and pronounced “じょうずいう”. But if there could be Kyushu-specific one, it should be pronounced differently.

This one is much more straightforward than the previous sentence once you recognize the dialect pieces.

もう、あんたまで上手言うごとなって。

I’d segment it like this:

もう、|あんたまで|上手言う|ごと|なって。

or in standard Japanese:

もう、あなたまでお世辞を言うようになって。

Meaning:

“Oh, now you’ve started flattering me too.”

“Come on, now even you’re saying flattering things.”

The dialect pieces are:

  • あんた = あなた
  • 上手言う = お世辞を言う、うまいことを言う
  • ごと = ように
  • ~なって = ~になって

So:

上手言うごとなって

= お世辞を言うようになって


About 「上手言う」

I don’t think this is a special Kyushu pronunciation.

It is simply:

上手言う

In other words, じょうずいう.

Here, 上手 doesn’t literally mean “skillful.” It’s functioning idiomatically as:

  • うまいことを言う
  • 相手を持ち上げる
  • お世辞を言う

So 上手言う is closer to “say nice things (to flatter someone)” than “speak well.”


「ごと」

This is one of those wonderfully productive Kyushu forms.

You’ll hear things like:

  • 泣くごとある = 泣くようだ
  • 好きなごとある = 好きなようだ
  • するごとなる = するようになる

So:

上手言うごとなって

is literally

“have become someone who says flattering things.”


Interestingly, this expression illustrates exactly what you and your Hakata friend were discussing. If an AI tried to “repair” it into standard grammar, it might overanalyze it as something exotic. But native speakers simply recognize 上手言う as a fixed expression and ごと as their ordinary equivalent of ように. The whole sentence then reads very naturally.

Aaah, Kyushu-ben text is devastating me…This is the next one: いつでも顔ば見せにくらんね。
I think “くらんね” is spelled “来らんね”, but this context is usually phrased as “見せにこんね” or “見せに来ちゃらんね”.
I suspect this text is AI-generated Kyushu-ben, and “見せに来る” was wrongly conjugated this way. Or, perhaps there is some other ”くらんね” that I don’t know.

I actually think your suspicion is well-founded.

Let’s dissect it.

いつでも顔ば見せにくらんね。

The first part is easy:

  • いつでも = anytime
  • 顔ば = 顔を
  • 見せに = to show your face / come visit

The problem is exactly what you identified:

くらんね


Possibility 1: 来らんね (my least favorite)

If this were

来らんね

in many Kyushu dialects it means something like

“won’t come”

because

  • 来る → 来らん (negative)

Then the sentence becomes

“Anytime, don’t come show your face.”

which obviously doesn’t fit.

So I don’t think that’s it.


Possibility 2: 来(こん)ね

A native Hakata speaker would much more naturally say things like

いつでも顔ば見せにこんね。

or

顔ば見せに来んね。

meaning

“Come by anytime.”

This is exactly the sort of expression I’d expect.


Possibility 3: 来らんね as invitation?

Some Kyushu dialects use

~らんね

as a softened invitation:

食べらんね

飲まんね

But this is not simply “come.”

It’s a different construction, roughly:

“Why don’t you…?”

If the sentence intended

Come visit sometime.

I’d still expect something closer to

顔ば見せに来んね。

than

見せにくらんね.


Possibility 4: AI blended two dialect forms ⭐

This is honestly my leading hypothesis.

It looks as though something mixed

来んね

with

来らんね

and produced

くらんね

which is morphologically plausible but doesn’t ring true.

It’s exactly the sort of thing an LLM does when it has seen several neighboring dialect paradigms.


Your intuition

I think your instinct

“I expected 見せにこんね or 見せに来ちゃらんね.”

is much stronger than trying to rescue くらんね.

Notice a pattern in the sentences you’ve shown me:

Earlier AI produced things like

  • 不思議やたい
  • 不思議だたい
  • 不思議なれたい

which your Hakata friend immediately rejected.

Now we’re seeing

見せにくらんね

which also feels like it’s trying a little too hard to be dialectal.

That’s a common failure mode for language models: they over-compose dialect pieces that individually exist but aren’t actually combined by native speakers.


If I had to bet

If someone from Hakata texted me

いつでも顔ば見せにこんね。

I’d think:

✓ Perfectly natural.

If they texted

いつでも顔ば見せにくらんね。

I’d pause and wonder whether they were from another area, had mistyped something, or whether the text had been generated or altered.

So based on what you’ve shown me so far, I share your skepticism. I wouldn’t confidently call くらんね a legitimate Hakata expression without independent evidence from native speakers or a dialect dictionary. It has exactly the “AI-generated Kyushu-ben” smell that your previous examples had: internally consistent enough to fool a learner, but just slightly off in a way that native speakers tend to notice immediately.

Mostly easy to comprehend, except the part, “強かってこーかるごと”. Please break this down:
あの男、自分がいちばん強かってこーかるごと言いよって、ほんとみっともなかっちゃん。

This one is actually a nice example of Kyushu grammar stacking several small pieces together. The mysterious part isn’t one word—it’s several dialect elements fused together.

あの男、自分がいちばん強かってこーかるごと言いよって、ほんとみっともなかっちゃん。

I’d break it up as:

あの男、|自分が|いちばん|強かって|こーかる|ごと|言いよって、|ほんと|みっともなかっちゃん。

or, even better, interpret こーかるごと as one chunk:

強かって|こーかるごと|言いよって


1. 強かって

This is simply

強か = 強い

plus the conjunctive:

強か → 強かって

Equivalent to:

強くて


2. こーかる

This is the tricky one.

It’s almost certainly a contracted dialect pronunciation of

こうある

or

こうである

meaning

“to be like this”

In rapid speech:

  • こうある
  • こーある
  • こーかる

You’ll see this sort of vowel contraction fairly often in Kyushu speech.


3. ごと

As before,

ごと = ように


So

こーかるごと

is essentially

こうあるように

or more idiomatically,

as if it were so

like it were true


4. 言いよって

Another nice Kyushu feature.

Not just

言っている

but often carries a nuance like

  • keeps saying
  • goes around saying
  • has the nerve to say

depending on context.


Put together

Literally:

自分がいちばん強かってこーかるごと言いよって

自分が一番強いかのように言っていて

or

He kept talking as if he were the strongest.


Then

ほんとみっともなかっちゃん。

= 本当にみっともなかったね。


So the whole sentence is:

“That guy kept talking as if he were the strongest one. It was really embarrassing to watch.”

or

“He went around acting like he was the toughest guy. It was honestly pretty pathetic.”


One small caveat

The exact form こーかる isn’t something I’d call a standard, widely documented Kyushu grammar item in the way that , ばってん, ごと, or いっちょん are. My interpretation comes from the surrounding syntax rather than from recognizing it as a fixed dictionary entry.

Given the previous examples you’ve shown me (where you suspected some AI-generated Kyushu-ben), I wouldn’t be surprised if the intended meaning was simply:

強かって(=強いって)こうあるごと(=そうであるように)

compressed into 強かってこーかるごと.

If this sentence comes from the same source as the earlier ones, I’d keep a healthy dose of skepticism. I’d be very interested to hear what your Hakata friend says about こーかる specifically, because that’s the one piece here that I’d want a native speaker to confirm rather than declare with certainty.

, ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RSS
Follow by Email
Reddit